top of page
Writer's pictureRebecca Herbst

HYSA vs. High-Interest Checking: The New Battle for Your Savings

Updated: 6 days ago

For many years, high-yield savings accounts (HYSAs) have been a very popular choice for people looking to save and maximize their returns via high interest rates. However, the HYSA is now facing a serious contender: the high-interest checking account.


Let’s explore why!


A high-yield savings account is a great place to store your money for an emergency fund or for near-term goals, like saving up for a wedding or a down-payment. You’re able to earn a relatively high interest rate without the risk of having to invest your money. Online banks have used high interest rates, or annual percentage yields (APYs), as a competitive edge to attract customers and are typically able to do this because they have lower overhead costs and more limited services than your traditional brick-and-mortar bank. Good examples of HYSA providers include CIT Bank, Barclays, and AMEX. NerdWallet does a great job of keeping an up-to-date list of some of the best high-yield savings accounts.


However, one of the main complaints with the HYSA is that funds are not instantaneously available. You might need somewhere between 24 to 48 hours for your money to be transferred to your checking account. For some, this waiting period isn't a big deal, but for others, this lack of flexibility might feel painful.


To combat this challenge, high-interest checking accounts are gaining serious traction as an alternative to HYSAs. Many are offering rates that rival HYSAs, but with the improved convenience of being able to access your money right away. They also eliminate the need to manage multiple accounts since now you can combine your checking and savings account into one.



High-interest checking accounts are more of a rarity but they do exist in two main forms: (1) traditional checking accounts that simply offer a higher-than-average interest rate, like those provided by Axos or Sofi, and (2) cash management accounts which combine checking and savings into one and are provided by online brokerages or robo-advisors. Examples include Fidelity’s Cash Management account or Wealthfront's Cash Account.


Here are the risks of a high-yield checking account:


  • Lack of physical presence: Most high-yield checking accounts do not come from local brick-and-mortar banks, and so you’ll likely still do most of your checking account activity online. For many people this is fine, but some like the option to visit their bank in-person especially for a high-touch account like a checking account.

  • Risk of spending: Savings accounts are designed to help you save, not spend. If you have easy access to your emergency fund/home fund/wedding fund – you name it – you may not keep to your savings goals

  • Risk of fees: Some high-yield checking accounts require you to maintain a minimum balance or complete a certain number of transactions to earn the advertised interest rate. Failing to meet these conditions may lead to lower rates or fees.

  • Lower interest rates: On the whole, the interest rates you'll find for checking accounts are still somewhat lower than those of the highest savings accounts. That can change, of course, but it may mean you miss out on some earnings.


At the end of the day, I still personally like having a HYSA separate from my checking account. It keeps the money safe for what it is intended (my emergency fund), and I only touch that money with deliberate intention. Plus, I don't mind the extra percentage point on the interest rate in exchange for a little inflexibility.


To learn more about the types of accounts and how to prioritize your portfolio, sign up for our Learn to Invest course!



 

Disclaimer:

The information contained in the Yield & Spread website, course materials and all other related content is provided for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended to substitute for obtaining accounting, tax, or financial advice, and may not be suitable for every individual. Yield & Spread is not a registered investment, legal or tax advisor or a broker/dealer.


Kommentare


Die Kommentarfunktion wurde abgeschaltet.
bottom of page